Research suggests Gen Z loyalty can be more fluid and conditional than older generations’, but saying Gen Z is simply “disloyal” goes too far. Brand trust, familiarity, authenticity, experience, and self-brand fit still influence loyalty. What appears to have changed is the number of alternatives and influences surrounding every purchase decision.
How much power does a brand still have over Gen Z?
Written by Benoît Vancauwenberghe, Gen Z expert, keynote speaker, and author of The Gen Z Shift. For more than 15 years, he has researched, observed, and worked with younger generations across Europe through 20something.
Gen Z has not stopped being loyal to brands, but research suggests that loyalty is becoming more conditional. Brand heritage, awareness and trust still matter, while self-identity, peer recommendations, creators, digital communities and greater choice increasingly influence preference. Nike illustrates the paradox: it remains a highly powerful brand while facing more competition for younger consumers’ attention and preference.
What you will learn
- Why Nike’s current struggle does not mean Gen Z has rejected the brand
- Why awareness, brand equity, preference and loyalty are not the same thing
- Why Gen Z brand loyalty appears more conditional than automatic
- How retailers, creators, communities and algorithms are redistributing brand power
- What Nike can teach every established brand about staying relevant
Nike is still one of the strongest brands in the world. So why is it fighting harder to stay relevant?
Five years ago, asking whether Nike still had power over young consumers would have sounded almost ridiculous. Nike was more than a sportswear company. It was part of the cultural infrastructure. The Swoosh could turn an athlete into an icon, a sneaker into a status symbol, and a product launch into a cultural moment. Nike did not simply follow culture. For decades, it helped create it.
And Nike is still huge. It generated $46.4 billion in revenue in its 2026 financial year. Brand Finance still ranks it among the most valuable and strongest apparel brands in the world. Among almost 9,000 American teenagers surveyed in autumn 2026, Nike remains, by far, their favorite footwear brand.
Yet something has clearly changed. Nike’s stock is almost 80% below its 2021 peak. Its share of the international sports footwear market fell six percentage points in three years, to 23% in 2025, according to Euromonitor data cited by Reuters. Nike Direct declined 8% on a currency-neutral basis in fiscal 2026, while digital sales fell 12%. Meanwhile, brands such as On, Hoka, ASICS and New Balance have become much more visible in categories Nike once seemed to own.
So perhaps the interesting question is not whether Gen Z is leaving Nike. It is something bigger: how much power does any brand still have over a generation with more choice, more influence, and more ways of discovering what comes next?
Nike is losing ground. Nike is also incredibly strong.
This contradiction matters, because without it we risk telling the easy story. Nike is not a dying brand. Its 2026 revenue was $46.4 billion, essentially flat in reported terms after a difficult 2025. Its wholesale business actually grew 4% on a currency-neutral basis, and there are early signs of recovery in categories such as running and football. Reuters reports that Nike has recently gained five percentage points of premium running-shoe market share across North America and Western Europe.
Its brand remains extraordinarily powerful too. Brand Finance values Nike at $27.3 billion. Yes, that is down 7% in 2026, but Nike still carries an AAA+ brand strength rating. And then there is Gen Z. In Piper Sandler’s autumn 2026 survey of 8,934 American teenagers, 45% named Nike as their preferred footwear brand. Adidas was at 10%, New Balance at 7%. That hardly looks like a generation abandoning Nike.
But look at the direction. Nike was at 61% among US teens in autumn 2023. It is now at 45%. Among teen girls, the movement is even more striking, from 56% in autumn 2023 to 31% today. Among boys, Nike remains dominant at 56%, but that too is below the 67% recorded three years ago.
There is an important caveat. These are American teenagers, not European Gen Z, and the wider athletic category is also changing. Athletic apparel brands collectively fell from 47% of teen mindshare in autumn 2023 to 33% in 2026 as fashion preferences moved towards less athletic styles. Not everything happening to Nike is therefore a Nike problem.
And that may actually make the case more interesting. Nike can remain number one while becoming less dominant. You do not need to lose your customer to lose some of your power over them.
From owning the shelf to fighting for space on it
For years, Nike had another enormous advantage: distribution. Go into the right sneaker or sports retailer, and Nike was everywhere. That visibility reinforced its cultural dominance. What people saw on athletes, in advertising and on the street was also what they saw on the shelf.
Then Nike made a strategic bet. Like many large brands, it wanted a more direct relationship with consumers. It pushed harder into its own stores, website, and apps and reduced its dependence on some wholesale partners. The logic was understandable. Why allow a retailer to own the customer relationship if your brand is powerful enough to own it yourself?
But shelves do not like empty spaces. At Foot Locker, Nike represented 65% of merchandise purchases in 2023. By 2024, that had fallen to 59%. That is still enormous, so saying that Foot Locker “replaced Nike” would be wrong. What happened is more subtle. Retailers diversified, while brands such as Hoka, On and New Balance gained more space and visibility.
Nike itself is now rebuilding some of those wholesale relationships. In fiscal 2026, wholesale sales rose 4% currency-neutral while Nike Direct fell 8% and Nike Digital declined 12%. There is an interesting paradox here: Nike wanted to own more of the relationship with consumers. At the same time, the market created more opportunities for consumers to build relationships with someone else.
We should be careful not to claim that Nike’s DTC strategy caused its wider difficulties. Too many other variables could be at play, from product cycles and oversupply in China to competition and changing fashion preferences. Academic research does not provide evidence to support that causal claim either. What the case does show is how quickly the competitive environment can change when more alternatives become visible.
Gen Z is not brand-loyal. Loyalty has become more conditional.
This is where the academic research helps us move beyond Nike. A 2025 European study of Gen Z consumers in Greece found that online brand experience, image, trust, and loyalty were important predictors of purchase intention. The researchers describe Gen Z purchasing behavior as relatively fluid, with loyalty needing reinforcement through experience rather than simply assumed from historical preference.
Another European study, published in 2026 and conducted among Gen Z consumers in North Macedonia, found a large effect of brand awareness on purchase intention in its model, while brand equity showed a much smaller effect. This does not mean brand equity is irrelevant. The study measured intention rather than actual purchases, and the results may differ significantly by category. But it gives us an important distinction: knowing a brand, valuing a brand, and choosing a brand are not the same thing.
Research into self-congruence adds another dimension. A 2025 study of digital natives found that young consumers did not develop the same loyalty towards brands that failed to fit their self-image, even when influencer credibility was strong. Other studies point towards the importance of electronic word of mouth, peer recommendations, creator authenticity and digital communities in shaping Gen Z decisions. A systematic review of 78 academic articles on brand loyalty across Generations X, Y and Z also concluded that younger generations appear less automatically loyal than Gen X and more influenced by the digital environment in which brand decisions are made.
But we should not turn that into another generational cliché. Gen Z is not incapable of loyalty. Heritage has not become worthless. Familiarity still matters. Trust matters. Authenticity and experience matter. Strong brands still start with enormous advantages. What appears to be changing is the assumption that those advantages guarantee the next choice.
Heritage gets you into the game. It does not guarantee that you win it.
The real competitor may be optionality
Think about the environment in which Nike originally became Nike. Media was concentrated. Distribution was concentrated. Cultural gatekeepers were concentrated. A relatively small number of brands had the money, athletes, retail presence, and advertising power required to reach millions of young consumers at the same time.
Today, a 20-year-old can discover a running shoe from an athlete on Instagram, see On through Zendaya, encounter Salomon through fashion rather than trail running, rediscover Adidas through a particular silhouette, hear about ASICS from a sneaker creator and see Hoka on runners in the street. Tomorrow, the algorithm may introduce another brand. This does not mean brands have lost control completely. Nike can still spend billions on marketing, sign some of the biggest athletes in the world and launch products globally in a way most challengers cannot dream of doing. But it no longer controls all the routes through which desirability is created.
Academic research increasingly points in the same direction. Peer recommendations, user-generated content, creators and electronic word of mouth all participate in brand evaluation among younger consumers. One 2022 experimental study even found that when Gen Z participants perceived brands as exercising excessive control over influencers, they were more likely to avoid both the influencer and the endorsed brand. The brand still speaks, but it is no longer the only voice in the room.
And this changes how we should think about competition. Nike’s competitors are obviously Adidas, On, Hoka, New Balance and ASICS. But there is another competitor that does not appear on any market-share chart: optionality.
A young consumer does not need to leave Nike to weaken Nike’s dominance. They can own Nike Air Force 1s, run in Hoka, wear Adidas Sambas, discover ASICS through fashion and buy something completely different six months later. The relationship does not have to end. It simply becomes less exclusive. A consumer can love your brand without belonging to your brand.
Brand power has not disappeared. It has been redistributed.
For me, this is the more interesting interpretation of the Nike case. For decades, companies talked about consumers gaining power. What we may be seeing now is more structural. Brand power is being distributed across an ecosystem of brands, retailers, creators, communities, athletes, platforms, algorithms, and consumers. The brand still matters enormously, but it increasingly shares meaning-making with others.
That also helps explain why smaller brands can suddenly become culturally significant. They don’t necessarily need Nike’s advertising budget or global distribution network to enter the conversation. A strong product, a credible community, the right cultural signal, and digital visibility can give them access to audiences that once would have been extremely expensive to reach.
Nike itself seems to understand that something needs to change. Under CEO Elliott Hill, the company is rebuilding wholesale relationships, reducing the supply of overexposed franchises, reorganizing around individual sports and investing again in performance innovation. And there are already signs that parts of the strategy are working. That is another reason not to write Nike’s obituary. Nike could very well regain some of the ground it has lost. But perhaps that is precisely the point. Nike cannot simply rely on being Nike. The challenge is not awareness. Everybody knows Nike. The challenge is desire.
The lesson for leaders is not about Nike
Nike’s situation should interest any leader responsible for an established brand because the dangerous assumption is that decades of brand building create permanent authority. They do not. They create an advantage, and there is a difference.
Your awareness can remain extremely high while preference fragments. Consumers can respect your history while experimenting with someone else. Your logo can remain famous while another brand owns the cultural moment. Your brand equity can remain strong while your relevance slowly becomes less automatic.
This is why I would be careful with the easy headline that “Gen Z is killing brand loyalty.” They are not. They may simply be growing up in a marketplace where loyalty has to compete with unprecedented choice. More brands are visible. More people influence choice. More communities create meaning. More algorithms decide what gets discovered. Culturally, switching costs can be incredibly low.
Nike remains one of the strongest brands on the planet. That is exactly why its current struggle is so revealing. If decades of cultural relevance, global distribution, iconic athletes, and one of the most recognizable logos in history cannot guarantee tomorrow’s preference, heritage alone will not protect anyone.
For leaders, the question is no longer simply “How strong is our brand?” There is a more uncomfortable question to ask: If people already know who we are, why should they choose us now? Gen Z has not killed brand power. It may simply be forcing brands to earn it again.
There is no evidence that Gen Z has collectively abandoned Nike. Nike remains the favourite footwear brand among US teenagers in Piper Sandler’s autumn 2026 survey, with 45% preference. However, that figure has fallen from 61% in autumn 2023, and Nike’s decline among teen girls has been particularly significant.
There is no single cause. Analysts point to overexposure of established franchises, increased competition, Nike’s earlier shift away from wholesale toward direct-to-consumer, changing fashion preferences, challenges in China, and stronger competition from brands such as On and Hoka. Nike is now rebuilding wholesale relationships and increasing its focus on sport and product innovation.
Yes. Research suggests that familiarity, trust, and inherited brand knowledge can still influence Gen Z purchase intention. The more useful conclusion is not that heritage has lost its value, but that heritage alone may be insufficient to guarantee preference or loyalty.
Is your brand still relevant to the next generation?
Being known is not the same as being chosen. And as Nike shows, even decades of brand equity cannot guarantee tomorrow’s preference.
At 20something, we help brands understand what Gen Z and Gen Alpha are changing in their category, from expectations and cultural codes to loyalty, experience and brand choice. Through generational research, strategic workshops and keynotes, we turn those shifts into concrete opportunities for brands that want to stay relevant without pretending to be young.
From a 45-minute keynote to a category deep dive or full-day strategic workshop, we help brands answer one simple question: why should the next generation choose you?
You may also like these articles
Explore our collection of articles decoding youth culture, Gen Z, and Gen Alpha.